The Choice of IIoT Implementation: Long-polling vs SignalR and the Future of Manufacturing
Posted on April 05, 2023
In the era of Industry 4.0, manufacturing companies are being faced with a critical decision: how to implement the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) to optimize their processes and gain a competitive edge. One crucial aspect of this decision is choosing between Andon/OEE providers that use long-polling to achieve real-time information and those that use SignalR for true real-time communication. In this op-ed, we'll discuss the pros and cons of both approaches, with a special focus on network traffic and the potential trade-offs in real-time responsiveness. We will also consider the affordability of ProAlert, an innovative solution that leverages SignalR technology.
Long-polling: A Tried and Tested Method
Long-polling has long been a common method for achieving real-time information in manufacturing settings. It involves the client periodically sending requests to the server for updates. When new information is available, the server responds with the data, and the process repeats.
Pros:
- Simplicity: Long-polling is relatively easy to implement, making it a popular choice for many manufacturers.
- Compatibility: It works with most networks and devices, offering a reliable solution for a wide range of scenarios.
Cons:
- Network traffic: Long-polling can generate a significant amount of network traffic, as clients continuously request updates even when there is no new information.
- Latency: This method can result in delays in receiving real-time information, potentially affecting decision-making processes.
SignalR: The Path to True Real-Time Communication
SignalR is a more modern approach to real-time communication. Instead of the client repeatedly asking the server for updates, SignalR enables the server to push new information directly to the client as soon as it becomes available.
Pros:
- True real-time: SignalR offers a more efficient and faster communication channel, ensuring that critical information is delivered in real-time.
- Reduced network traffic: With updates sent only when necessary, network congestion is significantly reduced.
Cons:
- Complexity: SignalR can be more challenging to implement, which may be a deterrent for some manufacturers.
- Compatibility: Not all networks and devices may support SignalR, potentially limiting its applicability in certain scenarios.
Enter ProAlert: Affordability Meets Innovation
ProAlert is an Andon/OEE solution that has "cracked the code" by offering a cost-effective way to connect any work center using SignalR. By leveraging this cutting-edge technology, ProAlert is able to provide true real-time communication without breaking the bank. Manufacturers can now enjoy the benefits of SignalR without sacrificing affordability.
In conclusion, the choice between long-polling and SignalR largely depends on the specific needs and constraints of each manufacturing company. While long-polling offers simplicity and compatibility, it can result in increased network traffic and latency. SignalR, on the other hand, promises true real-time communication and reduced network congestion, albeit at the cost of higher implementation complexity and potential compatibility issues.
However, with innovative solutions like ProAlert entering the market, manufacturers can now experience the best of both worlds: true real-time communication with SignalR at an affordable price. As Industry 4.0 continues to evolve, manufacturers must carefully consider their IIoT implementation options and adapt to stay competitive in an increasingly connected world.